Right now in my clinical I’m observing the class learn to write a research paper. They are discovering the whole process and it is really amazing to see all these “light bulb” moments as they begin to understand how to write a paper while seeing, for the first time, that they can write a research paper. The teacher is really pushing them to think in very analytical ways which is especially critical as they move forward in their education. They just finished Mary Shelley’s novel, Frankenstein, and their paper topic has to answer the question, “What is a monster?” They can choose to answer this question however they choose but they have to back up their argument with the text itself and with another novel, a poem, a journal, and an interview. She wants them to have varied sources so they can begin to understand the MLA process of citing and documenting sources. All great. However, what’s more amazing is how they are answering this question and the ideas they have to back up their arguments. Some of their responses to “What is a monster?” include: depression, serial killers, greed, power, obsession, and genocide. I mean these kids are really, very intuitive and what’s even more exciting is that they are taking literature that they’ve read and are applying it to these topics. Good stuff. I’m impressed with their work and even more relieved that teaching writing (a task I find daunting) is not, in fact, so scary.
For example, today we learned a little bit about what might have been influencing Mary Shelley as she was writing this book. We came to the original title of the book, The Modern Prometheus, and learned Prometheus’ story. The gist of his legend is this: Prometheus stole fire from Zeus, Zeus got pissed, Zeus then tied Prometheus to a rock and had an eagle come and eat his liver. However, this happens again everyday as Prometheus healed each time only to be revisited by the eagle everyday for all of eternity. Anyway, they learned this story and then were asked: Why would Shelly’s original title, The Modern Prometheus, be applicable to the story of Dr. Frankenstein and his creation? I was, honestly, a little shocked at the complicated nature of this question. I mean, I had to really think about it too. Some of them, you could tell, were a bit intimidated by the question but all of them attempted to answer this question in an analytical way. They really nailed it. I was impressed and so was the teacher. Some of the students argued that Dr. Frankenstein was like Zeus and the creature like Prometheus and others argued the opposite scenario. Both were constructive arguments that they could back up with evidence from the text.
All this to say, it was nice to witness good work in the English classroom. Assignments like these will stick with the students as they write their research papers and when they go on to college writing.